The Sameness Problem in ESG Marketing — and 42 Contrasts That Fix It

Every sustainability vendor says the same three things: innovative, customer-focused, industry-leading. Every ESG report opens with the same sentence about “the transition to a low-carbon economy.” Every LinkedIn post about CSRD looks like every other LinkedIn post about CSRD.

None of it is memorable. And in a category where the entire job is getting people to act — to close a data gap before an audit, to align a portfolio before a deadline — being forgettable is not a small problem.

A LinkedIn post that circulated widely last year made this point better than any marketing textbook. It was about running shoes, not ESG. The line was simple: a pair of New Balance sneakers, “worn by supermodels in London and dads in Ohio.” Ten words. No claim of innovation. No mention of quality or comfort. Just two specific, slightly absurd, instantly visual contrasts sitting next to each other — and you understand the whole positioning without being told what it is.

David Ogilvy, one of the founders of modern advertising, put it more bluntly: the best ideas often start as jokes. Not because marketing should be silly, but because a joke and a great positioning line work the same way — they compress a truth into something surprising enough to remember.

Why sustainability marketing is especially prone to sameness

ESG communication has a structural problem that most categories don’t: almost everything in it is regulatory. CSRD, CBAM, SFDR, CSDDD, SB 253 — the same frameworks, the same deadlines, the same vocabulary, applied to every company in the market at the same time. When the underlying subject matter is this uniform, the temptation to write uniform marketing about it is enormous. “We help you comply” becomes the default sentence, repeated by every vendor in the category, including us if we’re not careful.

But regulation being universal is exactly what makes it fertile ground for contrast. The rule is identical for a mining company and a meditation app, for a €50B fund and a €2M cooperative, for a factory with a full compliance department and a family business with a fax machine. That gap — between who the rule applies to and how differently prepared they are to meet it — is where the memorable line lives.

This is the thinking behind TSN’s tagline: Not to comply. To lead. Compliance is the floor everyone has to clear. What we actually build content around is the distance between the companies still scrambling to clear that floor and the ones already treating it as a competitive advantage.

How we built the contrast series

For each one, the exercise was the same: find two real, specific, contrasting entities that the same rule, the same number, or the same deadline applies to equally, and let the contrast do the explaining instead of an adjective. Not “flexible reporting for companies of all sizes” — but a 300-page CSRD report and a 2-page board summary that both have to say the same thing. Not “supply chain visibility across all tiers” — but a steel mill in Bilbao and a textile factory in Dhaka that both live inside the same Scope 3 number without knowing it.

The result is 42 of these lines, one per module, each built to work as a single, standalone LinkedIn post — no carousel, no swipe required, no caption doing the heavy lifting. Just one image, one contrast, published a few times a week over several months.

The contrasts, by module

A sample from each of the twelve areas the series covers:

Carbon Footprint / Scope 1-2-3 Scope 1 you control. Scope 2 you buy. Scope 3 you inherit.

Finance / SFDR / EU Taxonomy A €50B sovereign fund and a €2M cooperative — SFDR asks them the same question.

Real Estate A glass tower in Madrid and a cork warehouse in Alentejo — EU Taxonomy doesn’t check the postcode.

SDG Goals SDG 13 doesn’t ask what you make. It asks what you emit.

Data Collection Your ERP knows your revenue. It has no idea about your emissions.

Reporting GRI, ESRS, CBAM, SB 253 — four frameworks, one team, one Q4.

Providers / Supply Chain ISO 14001 certified and a handshake deal — both end up in your Scope 3 number.

Investee Management 50 companies in your portfolio. 50 different Excel files. One deadline.

Product Passport (DPP) A luxury watch and a cotton sock — the EU doesn’t care about the margin. It cares about the materials.

Analytics A board that wants one number. A regulator that wants 400. Analytics has to serve both.

Policies & Governance A code of conduct signed by the CEO and one that lives in a drawer — CSRD will find the difference.

Cross-cutting Your sustainability report is read in Frankfurt, Brussels, and Sacramento. Write it once. Mean it everywhere.

Follow the full series

These are 12 of 42. The rest are publishing gradually on TSN’s LinkedIn page over the coming weeks — a few a week, one contrast at a time, no two from the same module back to back.

If one of these landed because it’s uncomfortably close to how your own reporting cycle actually looks — the 2-page summary trying to say what the 300-page report says, the Scope 3 number that’s really just a guess — that’s the point where compliance stops being enough and leadership starts being a choice you can make.

Book a 20-minute demo and we’ll show you what leading instead of complying actually looks like on your own data.

Not to comply. To lead.

wineyard